Logan Mediate, of Indianapolis, is accused of killing both William Smith, 45, and US Army veteran and father of three, 50-year-old Victor Pennell, near a vehicle in an alley on the city's far west side.
Police say the teen confessed to three individuals that he killed the men as they attempted to rob him of methamphetamine and money.
Mediate has a lengthy criminal record including battery, criminal gang activity and domestic violence charges.
For those of you readers out there that don't know what a Juggalo is think wannabe-gangsta from a trailer park or click here.
Regardless, a Facebook page created by Mediate is also available here.
Other sites frequented by the suspect include: